Guilt vs. Shame: How to Use Guilt as a Guide
- Tiffany Bentley
- Jun 21
- 6 min read
Guilt is one of those feelings that can linger in the corners of our minds, whispering things like, “You should have known better,” “You messed that up,” or “Why can’t you just let it go?”
Whether you're a woman navigating your career, healing from trauma, or simply trying to hold everything together, guilt can feel like a constant companion. Especially for women, and particularly for women of color, guilt often gets tangled with cultural expectations, generational patterns, and identity.
Let’s unpack the difference between guilt and shame, when guilt can actually be helpful, and when it needs a little more attention.
Guilt Can Be Helpful
Guilt can serve a purpose. It signals when we’ve done something out of alignment with our values. It might nudge us to apologize, repair, or course-correct.
For example:
You snapped at a friend during a hard day. Guilt nudges you to reach out and say, “That wasn’t fair. I’m sorry.”
You missed an important deadline at work. Guilt helps you refocus, make amends, and set better boundaries around your time.
This kind of guilt is situational and often rooted in integrity. It helps us stay connected—to ourselves, to others, and to our values.
When Guilt Comes from Old Beliefs
Sometimes the guilt we carry isn’t really about what happened in the present — it’s inherited. These old beliefs and stories become a kind of mental script we replay, even when they no longer serve us. This is especially true for women of color and those from tight-knit cultural communities, where expectations about sacrifice, responsibility, and loyalty run deep.
Generational Guilt and Cultural Weight
This guilt is often woven through family history and culture. You might feel responsible for healing family wounds or upholding traditions at the cost of your own well-being. It’s the guilt that says, “If I don’t carry this, who will?” or “I’m letting everyone down if I don’t do what’s expected.”
Questioning the Narrative
Part of healing is learning to question the stories we tell ourselves. Ask:
Whose voice is this guilt really coming from?
Is this belief still true for me, or am I holding onto someone else’s rules?
What would my life look like if I gave myself permission to rewrite the script?
When you start to question these inherited stories, guilt loses some of its power and opens the door to freedom.
Oldest Daughter Syndrome and Generational Guilt
If you’re the eldest daughter—or the “responsible one” in your family—you may carry guilt that isn’t even yours. You might feel guilty for setting boundaries with family, for not being available 24/7, or for living your own life. That guilt often comes from a deeply embedded belief that your worth is tied to your caretaking or compliance.
You may hear that voice whisper:
“You’re being selfish.”“You’re supposed to hold it all together.”
But guilt doesn’t always mean you’re wrong. Sometimes it means you’re growing.
Guilt Around Moving Away or Choosing a Different Path
Many women, especially first-generation professionals or daughters from tight-knit communities, feel guilt around moving far from home, choosing not to have children, or breaking family patterns. You might wonder if you're betraying your roots.
But what if guilt is a natural companion on the road to liberation?What if it shows up when we’re stepping into a life that belongs to us—and no one else?
Shame: The Deeper Wound
Shame is a heavy, silent force. Unlike guilt, which is about what we do, shame is about who we believe we are — fundamentally flawed, unworthy, or broken. This belief is often learned early in life through experiences of criticism, rejection, or neglect.
How Shame Affects the Body and Mind
Shame doesn’t just live in our thoughts — it takes up space in our bodies, too. Many people experience shame as a physical sensation: a tightening in the chest, a heavy weight in the stomach, or a sinking feeling that makes it hard to breathe deeply. Sometimes, it feels like a shrinking sensation, as if your body wants to curl up, hide, or disappear altogether.
This physical experience of shame is important because it reminds us that shame isn’t just mental — it’s deeply somatic. Our nervous system remembers shame, often long after the triggering event has passed, creating a persistent background tension that can affect our energy, mood, and ability to connect with others.
The Social Roots of Shame
Shame is not only an internal experience—it is deeply shaped by the world around us. For many women, especially those from marginalized communities, shame is compounded by layers of systemic injustices such as racism, sexism, classism, and other forms of oppression. These social forces send powerful messages that can make you feel like you don’t belong, aren’t worthy, or must constantly prove your value.
Imagine growing up in a society that constantly devalues parts of your identity—whether it’s your race, gender, class, sexuality, or cultural background. These messages don’t just disappear when you leave school or a hostile environment; they can become internalized beliefs that whisper, “You are less than,” or “You don’t deserve this.” This is why shame can feel so heavy and persistent—it’s not just about individual experiences, but about the weight of collective history and ongoing marginalization.
Because of these social roots, shame is not simply a personal failing or weakness; it is often a reflection of unjust systems that tell certain groups they are unworthy or invisible. This makes shame a political experience as much as a personal one.
Healing from shame, then, involves not only inner work but also recognizing and challenging the external forces that contribute to it. Finding spaces where your identity is affirmed, where your story is valued, and where your worth is undeniable can be revolutionary acts of reclaiming your power and self-love.
Healing Shame Takes Time and Compassion
The path to healing shame often involves reconnecting with your body and emotions in safe, supportive ways. Therapies like somatic work, EMDR, and narrative therapy can help rewrite the internal story of shame, allowing you to reclaim your sense of worth and belonging.
The “Shoulds” That Shape Us
The “shoulds” in our lives act like invisible chains. They’re the voice of society, family, and internalized expectations telling us how we ought to live. “I should be stronger.” “I should have it all figured out.” “I should put others first.”
How “Shoulds” Create Inner Conflict
These expectations often clash with our true feelings and desires, leading to guilt and shame when we don’t meet them. They set impossible standards that no one can really reach, making us feel like failures even when we’re doing our best.
Breaking Free from “Shoulds”
Breaking free requires awareness and permission. It’s about learning to listen to your own values and needs instead of the external noise. Start small:
Notice when a “should” pops up and ask, Is this really mine?
Replace “should” with “choose” — “I choose to rest today” instead of “I should be productive.”
Celebrate the moments when you honor your authentic self, even if it means disappointing others.
Living without “shoulds” is a form of radical self-love — it creates space for you to live authentically and with more peace.
Skills to Work with Guilt and Shame
You don’t need to push guilt away or force it into silence. You can get curious about it—and choose how you respond.
🧠 ACT Skill: Make Room for It
Guilt isn’t the enemy. When you notice it, name it gently:
“Guilt is here.”Then ask:“Is this guilt tied to a value or an old belief?”
You can make room for the feeling without letting it drive your actions.
💭 CBT Skill: Check the Facts
Guilt often distorts the story. Ask yourself:
“What evidence do I have for this thought?”
“Is this thought based on facts or feelings?”
“What’s an alternative explanation?”
“If a friend had this thought, what would I say to them?”
This helps you return to clarity instead of spiraling into shame.
🖱️ Self-Compassion: A Crucial Skill
In moments of guilt, can you treat yourself the way you would a friend?Instead of: “I shouldn’t feel this way,” try: “It’s understandable I feel this way.” Self-compassion doesn't erase responsibility—it makes it easier to carry with grace.
For more on how to practice this, check out our blog:🔗 Can You Be Too Self-Compassionate
Helpful Resources
If this post resonated, you might appreciate these:
Ultimately
Guilt and shame are powerful emotions that can feel overwhelming, but remember—they don’t define you. Healing comes when you recognize that you are the expert of your own experience, the keeper of your own truth. Guilt doesn’t always mean you’ve done something wrong.
Sometimes it simply means you’re doing something different—stepping into your own truth.
The key is to notice where your guilt is pointing: Is it guiding you back to your values, or is it rooted in old programming?
Because ultimately, Light, you are the keeper of your own knowing—no one else has that kind of power.
Shine bright and keep moving forward.
If you want to know more about who I am and what therapy with me looks like, you can learn more here.
Thanks for reading!
Written by Tiffany Bentley, LICSW Therapist at Somatic Women, offering online support for adult women in Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Vermont, and Florida.
Comments